• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Madalon Law

  • (877) IT-MATTERS
  • (954) 923-0072
  • Home
  • Legal Team
    • Joseph Madalon, Esq.
    • Leandro Carvalho, Esq.
    • Susan Lee, Esq.
  • Practice Areas
    • Property Damage
    • Hurricane Damage
    • Roof Damage
    • Water Damage
    • Amusement Park Accidents
    • Aviation Accidents
    • Bar / Nightclub Accidents
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Birth Injury
    • Boating Accidents
    • Burn Injury
    • Bus Accidents
    • Car Accident
    • Construction Accidents
    • Head and Brain Injuries
    • Horse Riding Accident
    • Lyft Accident Attorneys
    • Maritime Attorneys
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Negligent Security
    • Nursing Home Abuse
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Premises Liability
    • Product Liability
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Slip and Fall
    • Spinal Injury
    • Swimming Pool Accident
    • Theme Park Injuries
    • Truck Accident
    • Uber Accident Attorneys
    • Vacation / Hotel Accident
    • Wrongful Death
    • Class Action Lawsuits
    • CPAP Recall Lawsuit
  • Results
  • Videos
  • Blog
    • Articles
  • FAQs
  • Contact
  • En Español
  • Inicio
  • Nosotros
    • Equipo Legal
    • Biografia de Joseph Madalon
  • Lesiones Personales
  • Resultados
  • Videos en Español
  • Contacto
  • En inglés

Insurance Company Denies Uninsured Motorist Coverage for a Phantom Motorist Claim

Free Consultation - Call (888) 888-2535 - Madalon Law helps victims and their families receive compensation for their injuries in Uninsured Motorist Coverage and Motorist Claim cases. Insurance Company Denies Uninsured Motorist Coverage for a Phantom Motorist Claim - Fort Lauderdale, Florida Uninsured Motorist Coverage Lawyer

Legion Ins. Co. v. Moore, 846 So. 2d 1183, 1186 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2003)

This lawsuit was brought by the insured’s estate against Legion Insurance Company for their refusal to pay uninsured motorist coverage following a fatal accident that claimed the life of James Moore, an employee of Miton Spector Inc. while he was driving his employers truck on business.

The accident occurred on a rainy night in the Coral Gables area. Moore’s vehicle left the road and rolled over fatally injuring Moore. No other car was found at the scene; however, a witness traveling about a mile and a half behind Moore saw a speeding car in the vicinity of the accident when Moore’s truck rolled over. The witness also saw multiple sets of tail lights as the accident occurred. Prior to the fatal accident, Legion issued a policy of insurance to the employer covering the truck and driver and providing Uninsured Motorists coverage.

The UM coverage applied to accidents caused by the unidentified hit-and-run vehicles, but not to single-vehicle accidents caused by an insured. Moore’s widow (claimant) made a claim to Legion to recover benefits under the policy’s UM coverage but Legion denied the claim and requested the court to declare that the accident was not covered by UM benefits because it was a single-vehicle accident caused by the insured and that the claimant had insufficient evidence to support her assertion that the accident was caused by another vehicle. Claimant answered Legions action with the evidence provided by the eyewitness of the speeding car that caused the accident and therefore it fell within the UM coverage and requested the court to strike the Legion declaration against her. The judge granted claimant’s request to strike Legions declaratory action.

Claimant notified Legion that she was going to call an accident reconstruction expert to testify at trial. It was the expert’s conclusion that the probable cause of Moore’s accident was a speeding car that cut in front of his truck suddenly, causing him to steer sharply to the left and thereby spin out of control and roll over. This conclusion was based upon his study of the police accident reports, measurements of the tire marks at the accident scene, examination of photographs from the scene of the accident, and the eyewitness’s statement that he saw an unidentified car speeding in the area at the time of the accident. Legion requested that this testimony should be barred from trial but was denied by their request. Legion appealed the judgment to strike their declaratory judgment action. The appellate court stated that declaratory judgment actions provide important remedies in regard to insurance coverage questions, especially as to claims made by third parties against someone covered by the policy.

In this case it was a first party under coverage claim and that it did not have to decide whether the claimant could make a prima facie case based on the eye-witness testimony that the accident was a hit and run by a phantom vehicle and accident reconstruction expert opinion because the trial courts striking of Legion’s declaratory judgment claim represents that the evidence was strong enough support claimants case for UM coverage. The court also stated that this case was the same as a run of the mill denial of coverage based on the insured causing the accident. Therefore the trial court’s decision to strike Legion’s declaratory action claim was well warranted.

The main message that this case conveys is that insurers often try to deny coverage by finding a loophole that deflects their obligation. It is important that the consumer know their rights when they are involved in an UM accident or any other accident that insurers could possibly deny coverage on.

The accident attorneys of Madalon Law feel it is important that you understand the law and your rights. Contact our Fort Lauderdale law office if you have any questions and we will gladly go over them with you.

Areas of Practice

roller coaster ride with trees in foreground

Amusement Park Accidents

plane on runway getting ready for takeoff

Aviation Accidents

people drinking and dancing at a bar

Bar and Nightclub Fights

woman ready to get on a bicycle

Bicycle Accidents

emergency room sign at the entrance of hospital

Birth Injury

cruisde ship at dock

Boating and Cruise Ship Accidents

fire burning and burned skin

Burn Injuries

school bus picking up kids at bus stop

Bus Accidents

two cars in car crash at intersection

Car Accidents

constuction worker that got hurt working on job site

Construction Accidents

woman with head injury from a car accident

Head and Brain Injury

person riding a horse

Horse Riding Accident

cruise ship sailing on the sea

Maritime and Cruise Ship

medical professional with stethascope helping a patient

Medical Malpractice

motorcycle accidient with rider on the ground with injury

Motorcycle Accidents

security personnel at a concert

Negligent and/or Inadequate Security

nursing home patient laying in bed

Nursing Home Abuse and/or Negligence

man injured on ground from car that went through intersection

Pedestrian Accident

broken fence and cracked sidewalk

Premises Liability

sign wih the word defective spelled out

Product Liability

beach and palm trees at a vacation resort

Resort/Vacation Injuries

womans hands pushing away a man that is grabbing her

Sexual Harassment

yellow caution sign on floor with a person that slipped on the floor next to it

Slip and Fall

medical image of body and spine

Spinal Cord Injury

swimming pool with people jumping in the water

Swimming Pool Accidents

sign of walt disney world theme park entrance

Theme Park Injuries

semi truck driving on road

Truck Accidents

lady justice statue

Wrongful Death

Video Library

Blog

Understanding the Law

Fort Lauderdale

Main Office
100 N. Federal Hwy #CU5
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Map for Fort Lauderdale address
Phone: (954) 923-0072
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074

West Palm Beach

By Appt. Only
515 N Flagler Dr Suite P-300
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Map for West Palm Beach address
Phone: (561)-243-1003
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074

Miami

By Appt. Only
150 SE 2nd Ave, Suite 300
Miami FL 33131
Map for Miami address
Phone: (786) 401-5059
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map

Footer

Facebook

Twitter

Linkedin

Google Plus

YouTube

Instagram

Pinterest

We serve the following localities:
BROWARD COUNTY including Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pembroke Pines, Pompano Beach, Plantation, Coral Springs, Davie, Sunrise, Weston, Deerfield Beach and Miramar;
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY including Coral Gables, Cutler Bay, Doral, Hialeah, Homestead, Kendall West, Miami, Tamiami, The Hammocks, and Westchester;
PALM BEACH COUNTY including Belle Glade, Lake Worth, and West Palm Beach;
ORANGE COUNTY including Orlando and Winter Park;
OSCEOLA COUNTY including Kissimmee, Poinciana, and St. Cloud.
Areas Served

Copyright © 2023 · Madalon Law · Powered by: USAttorneys.com
Areas Served

X

Contact Madalon Law

    Contact Us

    Please prove you are human by selecting the House.