• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Madalon Law

  • (877) IT-MATTERS
  • (954) 923-0072
  • Home
  • Legal Team
    • Joseph Madalon, Esq.
    • Leandro Carvalho, Esq.
    • Susan Lee, Esq.
  • Practice Areas
    • Property Damage
    • Hurricane Damage
    • Roof Damage
    • Water Damage
    • Amusement Park Accidents
    • Aviation Accidents
    • Bar / Nightclub Accidents
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Birth Injury
    • Boating Accidents
    • Burn Injury
    • Bus Accidents
    • Car Accident
    • Construction Accidents
    • Head and Brain Injuries
    • Horse Riding Accident
    • Lyft Accident Attorneys
    • Maritime Attorneys
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Negligent Security
    • Nursing Home Abuse
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Premises Liability
    • Product Liability
    • Sexual Harassment
    • Slip and Fall
    • Spinal Injury
    • Swimming Pool Accident
    • Theme Park Injuries
    • Truck Accident
    • Uber Accident Attorneys
    • Vacation / Hotel Accident
    • Wrongful Death
    • Class Action Lawsuits
    • CPAP Recall Lawsuit
  • Results
  • Videos
  • Blog
    • Articles
  • FAQs
  • Contact
  • En Español
  • Inicio
  • Nosotros
    • Equipo Legal
    • Biografia de Joseph Madalon
  • Lesiones Personales
  • Resultados
  • Videos en Español
  • Contacto
  • En inglés

No Seatbelt Can Cost You Millions in Compensation

Free Consultation - Call (888) 888-2535 - Madalon Law helps victims and their families receive compensation for their injuries in Auto Accident and Car Collision cases. No Seatbelt Can Cost You Millions in Compensation - Fort Lauderdale, Florida Auto Accident Lawyer

Henry v. Hoelke, 82 So. 3d 962, 963 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2011)

No seatbelt can cost you million in compensationThis auto accident involved a collision where the defendant t-boned the plaintiff’s automobile while making a left turn into oncoming traffic, causing the Plaintiff’s automobile to rollover and come down on the driver’s side rendering the Plaintiff paraplegic.

On February 6, 2008 the Plaintiff, Egline Henry, was driving home with her 3 year old daughter and friend Lifaite Augustin when Defendant, Jena Hoelke, made a left turn into oncoming traffic striking Henry’s Kia. The force of the collision caused Henry’s Kia to spin in different directions, and rollover. The Kia finally came down on the driver’s side. Hoekle did not attempt to brake before the collision. Hoekle also acknowledged that she did not see Henry’s Kia until the collision. Hoekle blamed co-defendant Stephen McCulloch for obstructing her view with his 1995 Suburban SUV by pulling out of his lane to make a left turn when he saw Hoekle’s car approaching him. McCulloch did not witness the accident. What he was able to describe was the movements of the Kia after the collision. He described the Kia to fishtail and start to roll over. He saw the passenger to be half in and out with his head, shoulder and arm to be out of the Kia window. He could not see if Henry was wearing her seatbelt. Before the Kia came to a stop McCulloch saw Henry come partially out of the window and the Kia come down on her on the driver’s side while she was not completely ejected.

The vehicle’s passenger, Mr. Augustin, testified that he saw Henry put the Kia’s seatbelt on both herself and her young child and that Henry was still wearing the seatbelt after the crash while leaning towards the driver’s still constrained by the seatbelt. Henry corroborated Augustin’s testimony, and testified that she could not remember if she had taken her seatbelt off after the accident or if someone else had removed it for her. As a result of the accident, Henry suffered a dislocation of her 11tht and 12 vertebrae resulting in a pinching of her spinal cord rendering her paraplegic which her treating neurosurgeon testified that she would be most likely paralyzed for life.

Defendant present the testimony of two experts, Dr. Freeman and Dr. Burton. Dr. Freeman, an engineering expert recreated the accident stating that the Kia rotated 90 degrees, began to roll over on the passenger side first, rolled a quarter turn on the same side, then slide on the ground for 46 feet came up on its wheels and then went down again but this time on the driver’s side. Dr. Burton, a forensic pathologist and doctor of medicine, whose expertise was in determining whether vehicle occupants in crashes wore seatbelts, acknowledged that there was no solid proof that the plaintiff used a seatbelt and that he was unable to look at the seatbelts of the Kia because it was unavailable. Dr. Burton also testified that Henry’s medical records revealed no bruising or abrasions that would show within a reasonable probability whether Henry was wearing a seatbelt. In an attempt to establish that Henry was not wearing a seatbelt, Defense counsel asked Dr. Burton whether Henry could have been injured the exact same way by not being belted and not being ejected from the Kia partially in which he answered in the affirmative, explaining that seatbelts cannot protect passengers in rollovers because they are designed to protect against frontal collisions.

Before trial Henry motioned to strike Hoekle’s seatbelt defense, asserting that the record did not have any expert testimony or evidence to support the defense. The trial court denied the motion allowing the defense at trial. Henry later support her argument with a memorandum of law that argued that the defendant would attempt to establish that she was not wearing her seatbelt through witnesses who arrived after the accident when she was no long restrained which would allow the jury to infer from this circumstantial evidence that she was not wearing a seatbelt at the time of the accident without competent evidence and further infer that she was injured as a result allowing an impermissible stacking of inferences. Henry moved for the trial court to issue a directed verdict in favor of Henry, arguing that the defendant did not provide strong enough evidence to prove that she failed to wear a seatbelt and that her injuries were a result of that failure repeating her argument against impressible stacking of inferences. The trial court denied issuing a directed verdict in favor of Henry and the jury based on comparative negligence attributed 65% negligence to Hoelke and 35% to Henry awarding her $6.3 million dollars in damages which was reduced to $4.1 million.

On appeal for the denial of Henry’s directed verdict, the court of Appeals found that the defendant did not provide strong enough evidence to support that Henry was not wearing a seatbelt by failing to introduce any proof that she was not wearing it at the time of the accident. The court found that even if Henry’s use of a seatbelt could be questioned, there was no proof that failure to wear a seatbelt caused or substantially contributed to Henry’s injuries, a requirement that must be proven on causation for a seatbelt defense. The court stated that the connection between the causal relationship between the failure to wear a seatbelt and the injury cannot be uncertain speculative or conjectural and that in this case the evidence provided by the defendant was exactly that. The court concluded that the defendant failed to support the two prong seatbelt defense that the plaintiff was not wearing a seatbelt and that the failure caused or contributed to her injuries without impermissibly stacking inference. After all the finding of comparative negligence was reversed and Henry was awarded the full amount of damages. The big takeaway from this case is that when you or a loved one is injured in an accident, it is important that you know your rights and responsibilities because odds are the party at fault for your injuries will most likely try to find a way to attribute fault to you.

If you have been injured in an accident in the state of Florida and have questions about what to do next, you should contact the Fort Lauderdale law firm of Madalon Law. You can speak to an accident attorney and have your questions answered at no cost.

Areas of Practice

roller coaster ride with trees in foreground

Amusement Park Accidents

plane on runway getting ready for takeoff

Aviation Accidents

people drinking and dancing at a bar

Bar and Nightclub Fights

woman ready to get on a bicycle

Bicycle Accidents

emergency room sign at the entrance of hospital

Birth Injury

cruisde ship at dock

Boating and Cruise Ship Accidents

fire burning and burned skin

Burn Injuries

school bus picking up kids at bus stop

Bus Accidents

two cars in car crash at intersection

Car Accidents

constuction worker that got hurt working on job site

Construction Accidents

woman with head injury from a car accident

Head and Brain Injury

person riding a horse

Horse Riding Accident

cruise ship sailing on the sea

Maritime and Cruise Ship

medical professional with stethascope helping a patient

Medical Malpractice

motorcycle accidient with rider on the ground with injury

Motorcycle Accidents

security personnel at a concert

Negligent and/or Inadequate Security

nursing home patient laying in bed

Nursing Home Abuse and/or Negligence

man injured on ground from car that went through intersection

Pedestrian Accident

broken fence and cracked sidewalk

Premises Liability

sign wih the word defective spelled out

Product Liability

beach and palm trees at a vacation resort

Resort/Vacation Injuries

womans hands pushing away a man that is grabbing her

Sexual Harassment

yellow caution sign on floor with a person that slipped on the floor next to it

Slip and Fall

medical image of body and spine

Spinal Cord Injury

swimming pool with people jumping in the water

Swimming Pool Accidents

sign of walt disney world theme park entrance

Theme Park Injuries

semi truck driving on road

Truck Accidents

lady justice statue

Wrongful Death

Video Library

Blog

Understanding the Law

Fort Lauderdale

Main Office
100 N. Federal Hwy #CU5
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
Map for Fort Lauderdale address
Phone: (954) 923-0072
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074

West Palm Beach

By Appt. Only
515 N Flagler Dr Suite P-300
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Map for West Palm Beach address
Phone: (561)-243-1003
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074

Miami

By Appt. Only
150 SE 2nd Ave, Suite 300
Miami FL 33131
Map for Miami address
Phone: (786) 401-5059
Toll Free: (877) 486-2883
Fax: (954) 923-0074
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map

Footer

Facebook

Twitter

Linkedin

Google Plus

YouTube

Instagram

Pinterest

We serve the following localities:
BROWARD COUNTY including Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pembroke Pines, Pompano Beach, Plantation, Coral Springs, Davie, Sunrise, Weston, Deerfield Beach and Miramar;
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY including Coral Gables, Cutler Bay, Doral, Hialeah, Homestead, Kendall West, Miami, Tamiami, The Hammocks, and Westchester;
PALM BEACH COUNTY including Belle Glade, Lake Worth, and West Palm Beach;
ORANGE COUNTY including Orlando and Winter Park;
OSCEOLA COUNTY including Kissimmee, Poinciana, and St. Cloud.
Areas Served

Copyright © 2023 · Madalon Law · Powered by: USAttorneys.com
Areas Served

X

Contact Madalon Law

    Contact Us

    Please prove you are human by selecting the Plane.